Paul the Baker

Working in the throbbing heart of London, as I do, there are thousands of sandwich bars and cafes within a few minutes walk of my office, each attempting to to quell my lunchtime rumblings with a bewildering bounty of buns, baps, baguettes and benoîtons. It’s not easy, but I have a favourite: Paul.

From humble beginnings as a family business in Lille, the Paul chain now encompasses more than 250 stores in France, whilst worldwide the brand can be found on high streets from Morocco to Japan. In the UK alone there are nearly 20 branches, each serving up a delicious range of fresh sandwiches and fancies, with more than 100 types of bread adhering to recipes that date back more than a century. It’s glorious, mouth-watering stuff.

Some Paul bread, yesterday

My particular favourite sandwich is the mixte, a simple mix of crusty benoîton, succulent ham, creamy emmental cheese, and butter so fine it must surely have been suckled from the teats of velveteen cows by busty French milkmaids. It’s really quite something.

In early December I sat at my desk and ate just such a sandwich, each mouthful a treat of rare and dreamlike proportions. Halfway through, however, my blissful reverie was interrupted by a jabbing pain in the roof of my mouth. The source of this discomfort was revealed as I pulled out a splinter of wood an inch long and an eighth of an inch wide, square at one end and tapering to a sharp point at the other.

Being the concerned consumer that I am, I walked the remains of my lunch back to Paul and quietly presented it to the manager, leaving my details and explaining that I’d like to be notified if they could trace the source of the splinter.

Five days later, a letter was hand-delivered to my office. Sent by the company’s Head of Production, it went into great and reassuring detail about the steps Paul take to make sure this kind of thing doesn’t happen, and offered an explanation for the alien body in my bread:

The style and quality of bread that we make is dependent on a number of things: consistent temperature and reasonably high temperature to name but two. We also adopt and use full artisan skills so that each of our loaves, however small, are hand-made. To fully complete the picture, as a surface to work on we use stainless steel in preference to the artisanal beechwood tables called parisiens as we perceive it to be safer: having said that though we have a beechwood parisien in the bakery at Covent Garden which we have used in the past for bread workshops which we hold for our customers, staff and on occasion journalists. On 5th December the day before you had cause to complain, we had held one of the workshops and had transported the parisien for the purpose during which it had suffered some damage. That night the bakers used it as they were short of space. This is the only route which I can find that could possibly result in you finding the splinter that you did.

All very comprehensive, and highly plausible. The letter went on to list some of the bakery’s safety procedures, and suggested that I should come and tour their premises, to put my mind at rest. It rounded things off by promising to contact me within 24 hours to talk through the matter in more detail.

Now this, you might think, is great customer relations. And you’d be right, except for one thing: contact never came. Not a whisper.

So, after Christmas, I wrote back:

Many thanks for your letter of 11th December (attached). I thought I’d write as I haven’t heard back from you as promised, although I understand how things can get a little hectic over the Christmas period.

I really appreciate the lengths you’ve gone to investigating how the splinter of wood found its way into my sandwich. I’ve been a regular customer at Paul for several years, and I don’t dispute that your safety procedures are second-to-none. The reason I handed the sandwich back was not because I doubted this, but because I just figured you’d be keen to figure out if there was anything you could do to prevent similar incidents from occurring again.

I’ve continued to shop at Paul (albeit at your branch on Old Compton St) and have no plans to stop. As for the offer to inspect your premises, I’d be delighted to do so: not because I need convincing about your food safety procedures, but because I like your cakes and sandwiches. The Mixte is a particular favourite, as are the macaroons.

And guess what? Nothing. Nada. Zero. Zilch. Or, as they say in France, rien.

The annoying thing about this entire episode is that I wasn’t all that perturbed by the splinter, despite the fact that it could have torn a gaping hole in my throat, leaving me writhing on the floor gasping hopelessly for air as visions of my woefully unfulfilled life passed swiftly before my eyes; no, I took the sandwich back, not because I doubted the safety of Paul’s methods, or because I thought there was a genuine threat to public health, or even because I wanted a refund or a replacement (I didn’t ask for either). I returned it because I thought they’d be keen to get to the bottom of the matter, to ensure it couldn’t happen again.

What has dismayed me is that they’ve resolutely failed to deliver on their promise to talk through the matter and invite me to their premises, despite my prompting. It’s more than two months later, and not a peep. 48 hours has stretched into 72 days, and I’ve started to use a different branch of Paul, too embarrassed to return to my favourite Bedford St outlet while the matter remains unresolved, instead frequenting their smaller, less salubrious shop on Old Compton Street.

I am not happy.

Update: I’m much happier now.


  1. Threaten to turn up with Weird Naked Guy. You’ll get your shop tour within ten minutes.

  2. My nearest Paul is the one in Holland Park. Before Christmas, for obscure reasons, I was in urgent need of mini macaroons. Paul had none, which discomfited me in the way one can be discomfited at no other time except just before Christmas. The staff almost brought a tear to my eye — a false memory, a nostalgia for a level of customer service that I’ve probably never actually experienced — by insisting on taking down my number because they were hoping for an emergency transfer of mini macaroons from another branch later that day, and they guaranteed to call me, either way, and a Joyeux Noel to you, sir, it’s no problem at all, delighted to.

    Need I add that they didn’t call?

  3. It’s a bit of a worry that their great food has caused you to display such impotent consumer power. I suggest going elsewhere for sanwiches. I hear Pret a Manger are good.

  4. You wanted a tour of the place? But….but….you could have got the tastiest kind of food of all…free food!

    The sad truth is that the squeaky-wheel gets the oil. You should’a walked into the shop where you got it at its busiest time with half a bottle of ketchup dribbling out of your shirt collar for blood and not stopped shouting about how you are about to take the splinter to your lawyer until they gave you a ubersized hamper of Mixte (mmmmsounds lush) and macaroons.

    Great post, you cooking anything horrific these days?

  5. they also don’t ship to Philadelphia. even the Florida location. grr

  6. So Fras, I was just about to email your website link to the Paul management (via contacts on their wbsite) to spice things up a bit.

    Would that be overstepping the mark?

    PS: Went to see Rose Tattoo last night. Very, very impressive for ‘old rockers’.

  7. I’d say it would be unfair to publish such remarks without making the subject aware of them and giving them the opportunity to respond. Send it.

  8. Splinter in French is “eclat” – intriguingly close to the spelling of “eclair”. Just saying.

  9. Your tale of Paul
    Me doth appal –
    Not just the lethal sliver,
    But their failure to deliver….

    Maybe your time is better spent
    In giving up their mixte for Lent,
    Hopefully Paul will then feast yer
    With lots of yummy oeufs for Easter??

    Blessings, Jill

  10. oh, i’m a bit worried now! we’re getting a pauls to run our cafe at the national maritime museum, but the thought of finding splinters (maybe off cuts of driftwood) in my sarnies is rather off putting.

    providing they give us the 30% discount like the current cafe, i just might be able to pop by…

  11. I am sorry to hear about your experience with PAUL’s.

    My family & friends & I have been going there for years & years and we have all always had good experiences. Excellent food, great customer service. I think you were just unlucky really.

    Lets face it these kinds of things can happen in the best of companies. I agree its bad that you did not hear back, but there may a reason.

    Sometimes you also just have to let go.

    I got food poisoning from sushi from Pret (I know, who buys sushi from a sanwich shop anyway). I know for sure it was the sushi. I was ill for 3 days. I complained & all I was offered was a refund.

    My best friend got a chicken bone stuck in her tooth from a chicken sandwich from Pret as well. She had to go to the dentist, it cost her £75. They never offered her a single thing.

    My husband had so many bad experiences at Startbucks.

    Despite all this we still go to these places, its not a sign that the comapany is bad.

    Its a wonderful day today isn’t it, you all have a good one.

  12. I disagree. Of course these kinds of things can happen – like I said, I’m certain the splinter was a one-off, and I wasn’t too bothered by it.

    What annoyed me was that the company made a promise then failed to keep it. There’s no excuse for that at all, especially as they were reminded.

  13. Phantom Zephyr, what is it that would make a company ‘bad’ then? If selling rotten food that gives you food poisoning is ok, what is it that you would find unacceptable?

    Just curious.

  14. Quite right. If your husband has had “so many bad experiences at Starbucks”, then the fact that he keeps going back makes him a masochist, not a beacon of enlightened consumer tolerance.